The Idea of the Withering Away of Law in the Early Soviet Legal Philosophy (1917–1930)
https://doi.org/10.22394/2686-7834-2023-2-67-76
Abstract
In the legal literature, the traditional idea is that Soviet legal scholars until the early 1930s rationally expected the withering away of law as socialism was being built. In this regard, this article aims to critically review the views on this problem that existed in the USSR and to check if such a theory (group of theories) really existed. To do this, the author checked the internal logic and detailing of the views of some leading Soviet legal philosophers (P. I. Stuchka, E. B. Pashukanis, M. A. Reisner, and I. P. Razumovsky). Their views on the problem of the withering away of the law were also compared with other elements of their scientific theories and with the provisions of classical Marxism.
It has been established that none of the considered works contains a full-fledged scientific theory of the withering away of law. P. I. Stuchka never supported this idea, and in his works, he wrote about the “withering away” of only certain liberal legal doctrines (freedom of contract, the autonomy of will, etc.). E. B. Pashukanis, known as the most influential Soviet legal nihilist, argued that the law would be completely replaced by technical norms, but did not provide any explanation for this statement. In many contemporary phenomena of politics and economics, he saw signs of the degradation of law but did not explain in any way how this would lead to the withering away of law itself. The replacement of law by technical norms was also predicted by M. A. Reisner, but his view was even more general — the law should have disappeared by itself when universal equality and justice would have been established in society. The philosopher I. P. Razumovsky also described the withering away of law only in general and, apparently, saw it as nothing more than an ideological stamp.
The inability to formulate a detailed theory of the withering away of law, we believe, demonstrates the stability of the Western tradition in the face of many years of determined attempts to deconstruct it.
About the Author
G. T. Bogatyrev
National Research University Higher School of Economics
Russian Federation
Russian Federation
Georgy T. Bogatyrev, postgraduate student, consultant in the Department of Strategic Development of the Financial Market at the Bank of Russia
Moscow
References
1. On the Offensive Along the Entire Front [V nastuplenie po vsemu frontu]. Soviet State and the Revolution of Law [Sovetskoe gosudarstvo i revoljucija prava], 1930. No. 11–12. P. 5. (In Rus.)
2. Zhukov, V. N. Sociology of Law in Russia: the Second Half of the 19th — the First Third of the 20th Century (Theoretical and Methodological Aspect). [Sociologija prava v Rossii: vtoraja polovina XIX — pervaja tret’ XX v. (teoretikometodologicheskij aspekt)]: PhD thesis. M., 2015. 367 p. (In Rus.)
3. Medushevsky, A. N. Political Thought and Discussions of the 20s of the XX Century [Politicheskaja mysl’ i diskussii 20-h godov XX v]. Political Science [Polit. nauka]. 2001. No. 1. P. 104–175. (In Rus.)
4. Nersesyants, V. S. Philosophy of Law: Textbook. [Filosofija prava: ucheb.] M.: Infra-M: Norma, 1997. 647 p. (In Rus.)
5. Pashukanis, E. B. General Theory of Law and Marxism. New York: Routledge, 2002. 195 p. (In Rus.)
6. Pashukanis, E. B. The Situation on the Theoretical Legal Front (On Some Results of the Discussion) [Polozhenie na teoreticheskom pravovom fronte (K nekotorym itogam diskussii)]. Soviet State and the Revolution of Law [Sovetskoe gosudarstvo i revoljucija prava], 1930. No. 11–12. P. 16–49. (In Rus.)
7. Pashukanis, E. B. Economics and Legal Regulation [Jekonomika i pravovoe regulirovanie]. Revolution of law [Revoljucija prava], 1929. No. 4. P. 12–32.
8. Razumovsky, I. P. Problems of the Marxist Theory of Law [Problemy marksistskoj teorii prava]. M., 1925. 136 p. (In Rus.)
9. Reisner, M. A. Law. Our law. Foreign law. Common law. [Nashe pravo. Chuzhoe pravo. Obshhee parvo] L., 1925. 276 p. (In Rus.)
10. Stuchka, P. I. 13 Years of Struggle for the Revolutionary Marxist Theory of Law: Collection of articles 1917–1930 [13 let bor’by za revoljucionno-marksistskuju teoriju prava : sbornik statej, 1917–1930]. M., 1931. 238 p. (In Rus.)
11. Stuchka, P. I. Selected Works on the Marxist-Leninist Theory of Law [Izbrannye proizvedenija po marksistsko-leninskoj teorii prava] / Comp. G. Ya. Klyava Riga: Latv. state publishing house, 1964. 748 p. (In Rus.)
12. Sheptalin, A. A. The Formation of Quasi-Marxist Legal Understanding in Soviet Legal Science in the 1920s–1930s [Formirovanie kvazimarksistskogo pravoponimanija v sovetskoj juridicheskoj nauke v 1920–1930-e gg.]. Lex Russica, 2022. Vol. 75. No. 4. P. 128–142. (In Rus.)
13. Engels, F. The Origin of the Family, Private Property and the State [Proishozhdenie sem’i, chastnoj sobstvennosti i gosudarstva] / K. Marx and F. Engels. Compositions [K. Marks i F. Eengels. Sochinenija]. 2nd ed. Moscow: Politizdat, 1961. T. 21. P. 173.
14. Bodenheimer, E. Impasse of Soviet Legal Philosophy. Cornell L. Rev., 1952. Vol. 38. Art. 2.
15. Bodenheimer, E. Review on Selected Writings on Soviet Law and Marxism by P. I. Stuchka. The American Journal of Comparative Law. Vol. 38. No. 1 (Winter, 1990). P. 196–199.
16. Sharlet, R., Maggs, P., Beirne P. P. I. Stuchka and Soviet Law / Revolution in Law: Contributions to the Legal Development of Soviet Legal Theory, 1917–1938. Taylor and Francis, 2017. P. 45–60.
Review
For citations:
Bogatyrev G.T. The Idea of the Withering Away of Law in the Early Soviet Legal Philosophy (1917–1930). Theoretical and Applied Law. 2023;(2):67-76. (In Russ.) https://doi.org/10.22394/2686-7834-2023-2-67-76
Views:
358
Email this article 